Treasure Island

Board Game Geek Reviews

1. 6 out of 10

   Dan875

   Pros: - Unique Theme (Scavenger Hunt) - Number of Tools at Disposal (Compass, Ruler & Markers) - Every Man For Themselves (Competitive) - Hidden Information (Verifying Clues/Private Hints Creates Tension) - Bluffing for Long John Silver Cons: - Markers - Large Amount of Game Components - Fairly Long Game Time ~2hrs - Recommended Large Playing Area

2. 8 out of 10

   amiller01

   Wonderful experience; going to love playing this every time, but that's partly because the Treasure Island theme and the cartography mechanics are exactly what I wanted. I think it's also because of the relaxed attitude I take into this game compared to some who haven't enjoyed it: it's a free-for-all game, not an all-vs-one game, yes, but when playing as Long John Silver, I feel like the most enjoyable position to take is somewhere between an opposing player and a GM. That includes burying the treasure in a non-exploitative location and not being a stickler on its exact pinpoint location. For example, on my board, I'd mark the treasure and also describe the spot in writing ("a tree unlike any other tree in the area", or "under this boat"). It's my aim as LJS to make the game enjoyable for the others, whether that's giving a player not having a great time some tools to improve their chances, or making it harder for more savvy searchers. It's unlikely for LJS to win, but winning isn't even my aim unless the other players are having fun and doing a good job with the information at hand. Hosting the game as Long John Silver, it's just as satisfying for a player to find the treasure late in the game as it would be to reach the treasure myself.

3. 7.8 out of 10

   Butscher96

   Like the theme and mechanic, but miss the interaction between the pirates. Want to play in a team version next time..